Why People Choose Nutley

Nutley offers a rare balance of small-town community feel and everyday convenience, making it especially appealing to buyers who want strong local roots without sacrificing access to New York City.

🔹 A true neighborhood feel. Tree-lined streets, long-standing traditions, and active community events make Nutley feel personal and connected. Many residents know their neighbors—and stay for years.

🔹 Easy NYC access. With multiple bus options, nearby train stations, and quick access to major highways, Nutley is a practical choice for commuters who want flexibility without the chaos of living directly in the city.

🔹 Diverse housing options. From classic Colonials and Capes to multifamily homes and newer construction, Nutley offers a wide range of properties that appeal to first-time buyers, growing families, and long-term homeowners alike.

🔹 Strong local amenities. Parks, schools, downtown shops, and restaurants are woven into daily life here, making it easy to run errands, meet friends, or enjoy time outdoors without leaving town.

🔹 A place people grow into. Many buyers come to Nutley for affordability and convenience—and stay because it truly feels like home.

Below is a snapshot of Nutley’s current housing market, followed by a deeper look at neighborhoods, schools, and daily life in town.

Nutley

Welcome to Nutley. Our local team provides clear, data-driven market insights and real-world context to help you make confident decisions. Reach out anytime with questions about this community or the local housing market.

Average Sales Price

Median Sales Price

Total Listings

28,096

Population

Neighborhoods & Housing Styles in Nutley

Nutley is made up of several distinct residential areas, each offering a slightly different feel—from quiet, tree-lined streets to locations closer to parks, schools, and commuter routes.

Most homes in Nutley are single-family residences, with a mix of classic Colonials, Capes, ranch-style homes, and well-maintained multifamily properties. You’ll also find a smaller number of condos and townhome-style options, though inventory in these categories tends to be limited.

This variety makes Nutley appealing to a wide range of buyers—from first-time homeowners and growing families to investors and long-term residents looking to stay rooted in the community.

listing detail

Average Median

Bathrooms - -

Bedrooms - -

Year Built - -

Lot Size - -

Taxes - -

Population & Household Insights

Data provided by Attom Data

Population

Employment

Age Median: -- Years

No Data

Education Level

No Data

Living in Nutley: What Day-to-Day Life Is Really Like

From schools and commuting to parks, dining, and community events, everyday life in Nutley is defined by the details. This section highlights what residents experience day to day and what buyers often want to understand before choosing a neighborhood.

Schools

Nutley is served by a local public school district with schools spread throughout town, making it easy for many residents to access education close to home. Families are drawn to the community’s emphasis on neighborhood schools and long-term stability.

School options—including public, private, and nearby alternatives—often play a role in where buyers focus their home search within Nutley.
Commute & Transportation

Nutley offers multiple commuting options for residents traveling to New York City and surrounding areas. NJ Transit bus routes, nearby train stations in neighboring towns, and quick access to major highways provide flexibility for daily commuters.

Many residents appreciate being able to choose between public transportation and driving, depending on their schedule and destination.
Parks & Recreation

Nutley has an active parks and recreation system, with green spaces, athletic fields, and walking paths woven throughout town. From organized sports and playgrounds to quiet outdoor spaces, there are options for all ages and lifestyles.

Community recreation programs and seasonal activities play a big role in local life, especially for families and long-term residents.
Dining & Local Favorites

Nutley’s dining scene reflects its local character, with a mix of long-standing neighborhood favorites and newer spots along Franklin Avenue and nearby corridors.

Residents enjoy having casual dining, coffee shops, and small businesses close to home, while still being a short drive from larger dining hubs in surrounding towns.
Community Events / Culture

Community events are a big part of life in Nutley, from seasonal festivals and parades to local fundraisers and town-wide celebrations.

These events help create a strong sense of connection and are often one of the reasons residents choose to stay in Nutley long-term.